Am I misinformed about pit bulls?
My neighbors had the cutest little puppy, named Prince. I thought it was a Dachshund mix, or something. Well, a month passes by, and I see my neighbor in the parking lot letting a large dog off the leash. Until I hear her call its name, I wouldn’t have thought it was the same dog. It’s now about 35-40 pounds and still a puppy. And it looks like a pitbull. So I ask… and yup, it’s a pit bull.
My cat likes to be outside, and he happened to be out at that time. Prince was highly interested in my cat, who just hissed and swatted at the dog. Although Prince was just being playful, I’ve read that pit bulls often become aggressive as they get older.
Aside from the stories everyone has read, I personally know a guy whose cat was mauled to death by his wife’s super-friendly pitbull WHILE THEY WERE ALL IN THE SAME ROOM, and his wife couldn’t even control her dog. The cat died and the guy received 20 stitches after trying to free his cat from the dog’s jaws.
So what’s the deal? The neighbor said her dog is very friendly, because that’s the way he was raised. But does that make a difference? Are pit bulls predisposed to killing smaller animals (and people) no matter how they are raised?
There’s a large English bull dog and an American boxer in my neighborhood, too, and I’ve been highly amused when they play with my cat. Prince was just as friendly, but just knowing he’s a pit bull sets my hairs on end and I am no longer comfortable with letting my cat outside unattended. Am I unfairly prejudiced? Or is an unleashed pit bull a ticking time bomb?
*Aduil, thanks. But as for not letting my cat in the neighbor’s yard:
1. Cats do whatever they want. And they don’t take to leashes. I know, because I’ve tried.
2. There are no yards. I live in an apartment. She let her pit bull off the leash in the parking lot.
rios4230: I respect your choice of pet. You recognize that your dogs will tackle anything that runs and is smaller, and you keep your dogs leashed. You understand that your dogs were bred for aggression and they are inherently more dangerous than most other breeds of dog.
Are the owners who think their pit bull isn’t dangerous just fooling themselves?
Yes, Chihuahuas are also infamous for biting people, but they just happen to be a lot smaller! Doesn’t that make a difference???!?
*****”EDIT: I have a harness and leash for my cat and I take him outside all the time like that. If you are worried, don’t let your cat out when the dog is out or go out there and supervise. It’s not your cat’s area just like it’s not their dog’s area.”
I have a harness, and none of my cats will tolerate it. But don’t you think it’s backwards to insist I keep my cat on a leash, while my neighbor lets her pit bull off the leash??
… and even if I were to supervise, see the story I attached. That guy was my coworker, and I saw him in the ER covered with blood.
Ash: In the same breath, you say that pit bulls are bred for “courage and tenacity in the fighting pit” yet are not bred for aggression. Hrrm, ok. Then doesn’t the ability and inclination of the pit bull to “darn well finish the job” make it inherently more dangerous than most other breeds?
My brother was bitten by a lab, right on the cheek. Yeah, the dog was mean, but it didn’t clamp down and not let go till he was bleeding and dead. It didn’t even break the skin. It nipped and barked. So there is a huge difference, AFAIC.

October 14th, 2011 at 8:36 am
All dogs can kill. It’s unfair to be afraid of pits because they can kill. Labs can, terriers can, collies can… any dog can kill another animal if conditions are right.
I think that you are prejudice because that’s what the media tells you to be. If you’re worried about your cat then keep your cat out of their yard. Don’t be prejudice just because a pit can kill.
People can kill too. Are you scared your neighbor is going to kill you?
EDIT: I have a harness and leash for my cat and I take him outside all the time like that. If you are worried, don’t let your cat out when the dog is out or go out there and supervise. It’s not your cat’s area just like it’s not their dog’s area.
Good luck! hope he/she is cute!
Report this comment
October 14th, 2011 at 12:36 pm
Pit bulls vary, just like any other breed. They can have a high prey drive but it depends on the dog. If you’ve trained the dog properly and know how to read the signs, the dog should be fine. I’ve known many pitbulls to live in the same house with cats and never bother them. Base it on the owner, and that specific dog, not the breed.
I work in dog rescue, specialize in pitbulls.
Report this comment
October 14th, 2011 at 5:36 pm
i have 2 pit bulls, when my oldest was a puppy she was scared of cats, now that she is a year old she don’t like anything that runs fast. pit bull have a high prey drive. a pit bull will tackle anything that runs so i would just watch your cat. when my dogs go outside they are on a chain so they stay in my yard.a full blooded pit should not bite people, they were made to fight other animals, and when they got hurt people had to get to take care of the wound. so any dog showed any aggression to people were put down.
I work in dog rescue, specialize in pitbulls.
Report this comment
October 14th, 2011 at 11:36 pm
ANY DOG, ANY BREED, RAISED WRONG CAN BE DANGEROUS.
I raised and still raise pit bulls, even with cats, you should not judge them because of their breed. All dogs have the tendency to turn on they owner or another pet even when they are raised with them and around them, all breeds are a ticking time bomb. It is just like people, look at all these killers and what does they family or neighbors say about them, ” they were such a sweet child, never any sign of bad, ect…” So just because it is a bully breed you shouldn’t be predjudice.
I work in dog rescue, specialize in pitbulls.
Report this comment
October 15th, 2011 at 4:36 am
Any dog can kill. the media has brought bad attention to them. a chihuawha can kill if in right conditions as first answer said. And it varies on how the breed is raised.
I work in dog rescue, specialize in pitbulls.
Report this comment
October 15th, 2011 at 8:36 am
its a tough question i guess. Most of my friends had pit bulls and they were the most friendly loving dogs and i have always enjoyed them. They have great energy too and are great companions. I think there may be a problem with some of them being inbred though that may incorrect. It seems that some of the owners abuse the dogs and fight them and that is a problem. It seems that if they are in a loving home the pit does very well and makes a great pet. More often than not they are. Maybe the media “hypes” up their reputation and makes it worse than it really is, like many other things. In my opinion the media attacks more than pits. To me it is how they are raised and treated (like people).:-)
Jah Love
Report this comment
October 15th, 2011 at 12:36 pm
Any dog can kill a cat. it all depends on the dog itself and how it was raise. Any dog can also turn on anyone if they feel threatened. It is all on how you raise them. Pitbulls are acually on the lower side of the dogs who have aggression problems. people just say they are bad dogs cause they look mean and thats what attracts the assholes who want a mean dog. in the end it is all about how you socialize them from the puppy stage till adulthood. i have 3 pits and if anyone ever came and broke into my house my dogs would probably carry out the t.v. for them. mine are the biggest babies ever lol.
Jah Love
Report this comment
October 15th, 2011 at 12:36 pm
Any dog can kill a cat. it all depends on the dog itself and how it was raise. Any dog can also turn on anyone if they feel threatened. It is all on how you raise them. Pitbulls are acually on the lower side of the dogs who have aggression problems. people just say they are bad dogs cause they look mean and thats what attracts the assholes who want a mean dog. in the end it is all about how you socialize them from the puppy stage till adulthood. i have 3 pits and if anyone ever came and broke into my house my dogs would probably carry out the t.v. for them. mine are the biggest babies ever lol.
Jah Love
Report this comment
October 15th, 2011 at 5:36 pm
You are misinformed about pits for sure.
However, as a person who lets their cat out you take that risk that the cat could be killed by a car, a dog (pit or not) etc.
All dogs are dangerous–with the exception of the tiny breeds not because they can’t maul or attack but simply due to their size. Pits are not inherently more dangerous than any other dog.
As for your comment to rios4230… pits are not inherently more dangerous..they, like many breeds have a high prey drive (they are called American Pit Bull TERRIERS you know—most terriers like yorkies, jack russells etc. chase small animals, cats and sometimes pick fights with dogs)…they are not bred for aggression either they were bred for their intelligence, their tenacity/courage in the fighting pits and their gentle natures with people. Most pit people know that a pitbull probably won’t start a fight with another dog (some do though) but they will damn well finish it if another dog comes after them. Many do very well in homes with cats & dogs…some don’t though but other breeds are like that as well.
Equating animal with people aggression is ridiculous. If this were a lab that chased squirrels or cats no one would blink an eye and think ‘omg that lab is aggressive towards small animals–he could kill someone’ but because it’s a pit all logic goes out the window.
Now, it is possible that she got it from a backwards irresponsible breeder so that his temperament is not up to true type–which is varying levels of animal aggression/prey drive, being extremely intelligent and loyal and being very very nice to people.
That said…it’s your responsibility to keep your cat safe. Not hers. The pit in this scenario isn’t likely a bad dog…just maybe likes to chase cats like many other dogs of many other types. The moment you let your cat out you basically agree to take the risk that something happens to it. If it wanders around and ends up like I said getting hit by a car or attacked by dogs you’ve no one to blame but yourself.
It’s not like she lets the dog roam around…she is with him watching him in the parking lot and probably knows to keep an eye out for squirrels, cats etc if he likes to chase them.
As for the coworker..many breeds, once they have something are focused on it. Pits, with their tenacity, fall into this category. Unless well trained, when they got something (particularly a prey item like the cat) they ain’t gonna let go. Sounds like this dog wasn’t so no duh he didn’t let go. He didn’t bite your coworker though. The guy just jammed his hands in there and tore himself to pieces trying to get the cat out…it’s happened with my pit mix before. He’s so focused on a toy he doesn’t realize my hand is on the other end…but it’s not aggression towards me whatsoever.
Well to answer your question it is not the same thing. Courage means that they are brave and tenacity means to be determined basically. Determined and courageous does not equal aggression. They will finish a fight (and I DON’T mean mauling the other dog, I mean backing the other dog down) not because they are more aggressive or more dangerous but because they are better equipped to do it—it’s like pitting a maltese against a bird dog when hunting birds.
Of course the lab nipped and barked…different scenario. It’s not the same thing so don’t try to compare it. The pit wasn’t going after your coworker like I said, but your coworker put his hands in when the dog was focused on the cat in it’s mouth.
Jah Love
Report this comment